Исходный размер 1444x2178

Decolonial Strategy in the Space of a Modern Art Museum

Данный проект является учебной работой студента Школы дизайна или исследовательской работой преподавателя Школы дизайна. Данный проект не является коммерческим и служит образовательным целям
Проект принимает участие в конкурсе

«Museums are simply the world’s most luxurious warehouses for stolen goods.»

00 / Introduction & Manifesto 01 / The Museum as an Institution of Knowledge 02 / The Mechanics of Appropriation: How Objects Were Taken 03 / Case Studies: Colonial Collections Under the Microscope 04 / Rewriting Meaning: How the Display Alters Context 05 / Institutional Critique: The Fred Wilson Paradigm 06 / Radical Reclamation: New Curatorial Practices & The Future 07 / Conclusion & Systemic Takeaways

Concept

Whenever I walk into a traditional museum, I get a very specific, slightly uncomfortable feeling. The ceilings are high, the walls are clean and white, and cultural objects are placed inside glass cases like sacred objects. For a long time I accepted this as the «normal» way to present art. But if you look closer, you realize this visual language is not neutral, it is carefully constructed.

Исходный размер 2148x1612

The Great Court Architecture, British Museum // Queen Elizabeth II Great Court, London, 2024

It is a spatial system that shapes how we look at history through a particular and biased perspective, often described in theory as the «colonial gaze.» If we want to change how we understand history and culture, we also need to rethink the physical and visual structure of museum spaces.

Исходный размер 1080x775

Minimalist Pedestal Display, Contemporary Art Gallery // «The White Cube Layout», Architectural Space, 2024

01/ The Museum as an Institution of Knowledge

Исходный размер 2000x1154

19th-Century Institutional Library, Archival Reference // «The Architecture of Knowledge», Spatial Concept, 2024

Modern museums developed from earlier forms like the Cabinets of Curiosities in Europe during the 18th and 19th centuries. Over time these institutions positioned themselves as authorities on global culture. Collecting, sorting, and displaying objects from around the world was not neutral, it visually reinforced ideas of imperial control and ownership.

Исходный размер 3220x2493

Cabinet of Curiosities Engraving, Ferrante Imperato // «Dell’Historia Naturale», Naples, 1599

Museums didn’t just collect objects. They created strict, Eurocentric systems of time and value, where Western art was placed at the top of cultural development, while non-Western cultures were often placed into a vague and simplified «primitive» past.

Ethnographic Masks, Andreas Lommel // «Masks: Their Meaning and Function», 1972

When you place two masks side-by-side on a flat white page, you immediately kill their original purpose. These objects were not originally made to be silently observed under museum lighting — they were part of movement, ritual, sound, and community. By placing them in a flat, comparative layout, the display turns them into isolated visual objects, removing their original context. In a way, it treats them like specimens pinned for study, rather than living cultural forms.

Исходный размер 5067x738

Late 19th-Century Iñupiat Masks, Sheldon Jackson Museum

The neoclassical architecture of early public museums was not only an aesthetic decision. Large staircases, monumental columns, and high ceilings were designed to shape the visitor’s behavior. These spatial choices create a feeling of smallness and distance, positioning the visitor as passive and intellectually subordinate within the space.

Great monuments are raised up like dikes, opposing the logic and majesty of authority against all disturbing elements. It is in the form of the cathedral or palace that the State speaks to the multitudes and imposes silence upon them.

— Georges Bataille, Architecture (1929)

Museum labels and text panels often reinforce this authority. By using neutral, anonymous, third-person language, the institution removes visible signs of authorship and bias. This creates an impression that the information presented is objective and universally true, even though it is always shaped by institutional perspective.

In many cases, labels simplify or generalize origins. Instead of naming specific cultural or regional contexts, they might list information such as «Maker: unknown» or reduce complex geographies to broad categories like «West Africa» or «Oceania.» This kind of labeling flattens difference and removes historical specificity.

post

Brass Plaque showing a dignitary 16th — 17th Century

Edo Peoples Benin City, Nigeria

Acquired during the 1897 British military expedition.

In many traditional museum displays, European masterpieces are given spacious galleries, controlled lighting, and careful framing, while indigenous artifacts are often placed in dense, crowded glass cases. This difference in presentation changes how objects are perceived. Sacred and spiritual objects, in particular, can be reduced to the status of «specimens, ” stripped of their original meaning and treated as if they belong to an evolutionary timeline rather than a living culture.

Louvre museum gallery interior painting vs Pitt Rivers museum crowded cases

Within this system, European artworks are typically presented through ideas of aesthetic value, authorship, and individual artistic genius. In contrast, artistic production from other parts of the world is often categorized as craft or ethnographic material, rather than recognized as fine art in the same sense. This creates a clear imbalance in how cultural value is assigned.

Overall, the traditional museum is not a neutral space of cultural appreciation. It functions as a spatial and visual system that reinforces historical hierarchies formed during the colonial period.

02/ The Mechanics of Appropriation.

Исходный размер 3830x3109

Cavalry Maneuvers, Camp de Châlons, Gustave Le Gray // «The Architecture of Imperial Order», 1857

Most colonial artifacts did not arrive in Europe via peaceful trade. Instead, they were taken during military campaigns, expeditions, and colonial occupations. In this context, objects often functioned as trophies of conquest, physically marking territorial and cultural domination.

Исходный размер 1280x720

Engraving of the Battle of Naseby, 1645

In the 19th century, European botanical, anthropological, and geographical expeditions often worked alongside military operations. While territories were being mapped and documented, cultural objects were also being collected and removed from their places of origin. These processes were closely connected rather than separate scientific activities.

Even when objects were described as «purchased, ” these transactions were rarely equal. Sacred or royal items were often obtained under strong power imbalances, sometimes for very low prices and in conditions shaped by pressure or threat.

Once these objects arrived in Europe, detailed information about their origins was frequently reduced or removed. The names of specific artists, rulers, or communities were often left out of records and replaced with broad regional labels. This process erased provenance and disconnected objects from their original social and cultural contexts.

The colonial museum, as conceived in the second half of the nineteenth century… was a weapon, a method and a device used to legitimize, extend and naturalize new extremes of violence.

— Dan Hicks
The Brutish Museums

When a museum uses the term 'contested histories, ' it is nine times out of ten a euphemism for glossing over the fact that these objects were stolen in deeply violent circumstances, or taken as part of looting after conflict.

— Alice Procter
The Whole Picture

Auction houses in London, Paris, and Berlin quickly financialized these looted goods, turning sacred ancestral relics into luxury commodities for private collectors and state museums.

Visual collections were built on systemic displacement. The clean and «beautiful» appearance of museum displays often hides this history. What is not shown is the violence and unequal power that made these collections possible in the first place.

03/ Case Studies: Colonial Collections Under the Microscope

The Benin Bronzes were taken from the Kingdom of Benin during the British Punitive Expedition of 1897. After the raid, these brass plaques and other objects were sold to Western museums, and the profits were used to help fund the military operation itself.

Photographs from this period show British soldiers posing with large amounts of confiscated objects, including plaques and ivory. These images directly document how parts of major museum collections were formed through colonial violence and looting.

Исходный размер 2398x1750

Looted Benin Bronzes, Reginald Kerr Granville // «The Violence of Acquisition», 1897

The Parthenon Marbles were removed from Athens by Lord Elgin in the early 19th century. In the British Museum, they were presented as part of a shared European heritage, which disconnected them from their original architectural and cultural context in Greece.

Исходный размер 1600x1200

Room 18: The Parthenon Galleries, British Museum // «Institutional Camouflage», London

The Rosetta Stone was taken by the British military from French forces in Egypt in 1801. After arriving in Britain, it was quickly turned into a symbol of European intellectual achievement and displayed in the British Museum behind protective glass, separated from its original historical and cultural setting.

The Rosetta Stone

Исходный размер 1237x259

The Rosetta Stone

The Rosetta Stone, British Museum

The Royal Museum for Central Africa in Tervuren, Belgium, was for decades a clear example of colonial propaganda. Its interior design and use of taxidermy presented the exploitation of the Congo as a «civilizing mission, ” framing violence and extraction in a positive, justified way.

0

Royal museum for central Africa, Tervuren, Belgium // Unrivalled Art, temporary exhibition, 2024

04 / Rewriting Meaning: How the Display Alters Context

When an object is placed inside a clean museum display case, its original function is removed. A sacred mask, for example, is no longer seen as part of ritual or community life, but as a static object for observation.

The mid-20th-century «white cube» gallery style is often described as neutral and non-ideological. In reality, its bright lighting and empty walls help erase context, making artworks appear disconnected from their histories and conditions of production.

The way museums organize space also creates hierarchy. Ethnographic collections are often placed in separate wings, lower floors, or darker rooms. This spatial separation can suggest, even unintentionally, that these cultures are less important than European classical art.

It was through the violent exercise of the 'imperial shutter' that objects were detached from their material and political worlds, rendered worldless, and inserted into the 'right' place in imperial-imposed timelines.

— Ariella Aïsha Azoulay
Potential History: Unlearning Imperialism

European paintings are usually carefully credited to named artists, while colonial or non-European works are often labeled with very general terms such as «Tribal Artist» or «19th Century Africa.» This removes the identity and professional recognition of the makers.

Many exhibitions are also organized in linear, one-directional paths. This creates a suggested timeline where visitors move from «early» or «primitive» cultures toward modern Western progress, reinforcing a simplified evolutionary view of history.

These design and layout decisions are not neutral. The museum space does not just display objects — it actively shapes their meaning and often reinforces an imperial way of seeing history.

05 / Institutional Critique: The Fred Wilson Paradigm

post

In his exhibition Mining the Museum (1992) at the Maryland Historical Society, artist Fred Wilson did not add new artworks. Instead, he worked with existing museum collections and re-arranged them in a new way.

For example, he placed decorative 19th-century silver objects in the same display as iron slave shackles. This simple but powerful combination revealed the hidden connection between wealth and slavery, and showed how museum collections are linked to histories of exploitation.

Исходный размер 1400x978

Metalwork 1793–1880 (Silverware and Slave Shackles) // Mining the Museum, 1992

Wilson also placed elegant historical armchairs facing a wooden whipping post. This setup changes the meaning of both objects: the decorative furniture becomes an unintended audience to a history of violence and punishment.

In another intervention, he used museum lighting in a critical way. He directed strong spotlights onto busts of well-known white historical figures, while leaving the empty or unlabelled pedestals of Black historical figures in darkness. This contrast made visible how museums can highlight certain histories while making others disappear.

Fred Wilson, Mining the Museum, Baltimore, 1992

It was kind of overwhelming for them. It was a good thing, but they couldn’t stay the same; that was the problem for them. You couldn’t put the genie back in the bottle.

— Fred Wilson

Instead of neutral, academic descriptions, Wilson created his own labels that used simple but unsettling questions like «Where am I?» and «Who washed these dishes?». These questions break the usual authoritative tone of museum texts and make the viewer aware of the hidden human histories behind the objects.

06 / Radical Reclamation: New Curatorial Practices & The Future

Contemporary decolonial exhibition design often challenges the dominant way of looking by changing the height and placement of objects. Visitors are sometimes forced to bend down, look up, or physically adjust their position, which changes the passive viewing experience into something more active and aware.

Some designers also use raw materials such as exposed scaffolding, unpainted wood, or shipping crates as display structures. These choices remind the viewer that the objects are not neutral or timeless, but part of a history of movement, loss, and displacement.

In addition, wall texts are no longer always single, authoritative statements. Some exhibitions use multiple voices in parallel, separating perspectives into different columns or colors, so that curators, indigenous communities, and contemporary critics can all be read side by side.

Исходный размер 1180x790

David Adjaye, Making Memory London, UK

Instead of rigid corridors and fixed routes, some modern exhibitions use curved, open, or fragmented layouts. This allows visitors to choose their own path, breaking away from the traditional linear and hierarchical way of moving through a museum.

In place of imperial maps that reinforce national borders, contemporary exhibitions sometimes use artistic or abstract maps that highlight indigenous territories and alternative spatial understandings. This directly challenges the idea of fixed political ownership and presents space as something more fluid and contested.

The future of exhibition design is not about achieving harmony, but about making the architectural scaffolding visible. Design must become an honest platform for debate and restitution.

07 / Conclusion

Exhibition design is never just an aesthetic choice. Every decision, from spatial layout to lighting to typography carries meaning. These design choices can either reproduce the old colonial way of seeing or help challenge and dismantle it.

Decolonial design aims to shift the museum from a closed system of collected and often displaced objects into a more open and reflective space. It encourages multiple voices, honest context, and a more critical understanding of history and culture.

Библиография
1.

Cabinet of Curiosities or Colonialism? [Электронный ресурс] / Art & Object. — URL: https://www.artandobject.com/news/cabinet-curiosities-colonialism (дата обращения: 17.02.2026).

2.

Georges Bataille Quote [Электронный ресурс] / QuoteFancy. — URL: https://quotefancy.com/quote/1085203/Georges-Bataille-The-great-monuments-are-raised-up-like-dams-pitting-the-logic-of-majesty (дата обращения: 22.02.2026).

3.

The Benin Bronzes: A Story of Violence, Theft, and Artistry [Электронный ресурс] / Khan Academy. — URL: https://www.khanacademy.org/humanities/art-africa/west-africa/nigeria/a/the-benin-bronzes-a-story-of-violence-theft-and-artistry (дата обращения: 01.03.2026).

4.

As infrastructure crumbles, British Museum plans to fix Parthenon Marbles gallery next [Электронный ресурс] / The Art Newspaper, 2022. — URL: https://www.theartnewspaper.com/2022/11/03/as-infrastructure-crumbles-british-museum-plans-to-fix-parthenon-marbles-gallery-next (дата обращения: 09.03.2026).

5.

The Parthenon Galleries, North Slip Room [Фотография] / Wikimedia Commons. — URL: https://commons.wikimedia.org/wiki/File:BM%3B_RM18_-GR,The_Parthenon_Galleries_1_Temple_of_Athena_Parthenos%28447-438_B.C%29+North_Slip_Room,-Full_Elevation_&_Viewing_North-.JPG (дата обращения: 18.03.2026).

6.

Rosetta Stone [Электронный ресурс] / Encyclopedia Britannica. — URL: https://www.britannica.com/topic/Rosetta-Stone (дата обращения: 27.03.2026).

7.

Unrivalled Art: Royal Museum for Central Africa [Электронный ресурс] / Art of the Ancestors. — URL: https://www.artoftheancestors.com/blog/unrivalled-art-royal-museum-central-africa (дата обращения: 05.04.2026).

8.

How «Mining the Museum» Changed the Art World [Электронный ресурс] / BmoreArt, 2017. — URL: https://bmoreart.com/2017/05/how-mining-the-museum-changed-the-art-world.html (дата обращения: 12.04.2026).

9.

Reinventing Africa: Museums, Material Culture and Popular Imagination [Текст] / A. E. Coombes; Yale University Press, 2004.

10.

Spaces of Experience: Art Gallery Interiors from 1800 to 2000 [Текст] / C. Klonk; Yale University Press, 2009.

11.

Inside the White Cube: The Ideology of the Gallery Space [Текст] / B. O’Doherty; Lapis Press, 1986.

12.

Fred Wilson [Электронный ресурс] / Middle Savagery, 2009. — URL: https://middlesavagery.wordpress.com/2009/03/03/fred-wilson/ (дата обращения: 21.04.2026).

13.

The Decolonial Museum: Spatial Disruption and Polyphonic Narrative [Текст] / P. Schorch; Museum Management, vol. 35, no. 4, 2020.

14.

The Adjaye Associates-Designed Basquiat Exhibition Looks Beyond the Myth of the Icon [Электронный ресурс] / ArchDaily. — URL: https://www.archdaily.com/983014/the-adjaye-associates-nil-designed-basquiat-exhibition-looks-beyond-the-myth-of-the-icon (дата обращения: 06.05.2026).

15.

David Adjaye: Making Memory [Электронный ресурс] / Adjaye Associates. — URL: https://www.adjaye.com/work/david-adjaye-making-memory/ (дата обращения: 18.05.2026).

Decolonial Strategy in the Space of a Modern Art Museum
Проект создан 27.05.2026